Pizza in Key Biscayne: 6 island options + Sunset Point
6 pizza options in the Village or at the Ritz, plus one causeway stop on Virginia Key. Compare style, current price examples, ordering, hours, and access before you go.
Quick answer
Which Key Biscayne pizza place should you choose?
For a destination slice, start with the Miami Slice pop-up. Tutto is the sit-down wood-fired pizza-and-pasta room, while Sir Pizza is the familiar local delivery staple and lower-cost whole-pie option. CRAFT works for a mixed-menu group, Domino's is the predictable chain option, and Stefano's is the Ritz-Carlton poolside choice. Sunset Point is a Neapolitan wood-fired causeway stop on Virginia Key before Bear Cut Bridge, not a Village of Key Biscayne restaurant.
Sources: miamislicepizza.com ↗ · tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ · sirpizzakeybiscayne.com ↗ · craftmiami.us ↗ · pizza.dominos.com ↗ · ritzcarlton.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · miamidade.gov ↗
At a glance
Compare the pizza places included in this guide
7 places checked August 31, 2026
| Place | Best for | Pizza & example price | Service & access | Published hours & sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Miami Slice Key Biscayne | Destination slice and takeout | Slices and full pies; the Key Biscayne page does not name a regional style or publish stable prices | Walk-in and takeout inside Flour & Weirdoughs, 19 Harbor Dr; no reservations and seating is not guaranteed | Check today — the official weekly schedule and live Toast ordering window conflict Conflicting schedules Checked Sources: miamislicepizza.com ↗ · toasttab.com ↗ |
| Tutto Pizza & Pasta | Sit-down wood-fired pizza and pasta | Wood-fired Italian; 8- and 12-inch whole pies; Margherita $13 / $16 | Dine-in, takeout, and delivery at Galleria, 328 Crandon Blvd #111 | Tue–Thu and Sun 11:30 AM–10:30 PM; Fri–Sat to 11 PM; closed Mon Checked Sources: tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ · tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ |
| Sir Pizza | Classic local delivery and lower-cost whole pies | Classic round pizza; lunch mini, 10- and 14-inch pies; cheese $7.10 / $11.85 / $22.70 | Dine-in, carryout, and delivery at 712 Crandon Blvd | Mon–Thu 11:30 AM–10 PM; Fri–Sat to 11 PM; Sun noon–10 PM Checked Sources: sirpizzakeybiscayne.com ↗ · sirpizzakeybiscayne.com ↗ · sirpizzakeybiscayne.hungerrush.com ↗ |
| CRAFT Key Biscayne | A mixed-menu group or an all-day meal | Neapolitan whole pies; Margherita Clasica $15.95 | Dine-in, pickup, delivery, and reservations at The Square, 260 Crandon Blvd #14 | Daily 8 AM–10 PM Checked Sources: toasttab.com ↗ · craftmiami.us ↗ · opentable.com ↗ |
| Domino's Key Biscayne | Predictable chain delivery and carryout | Build-your-own and specialty whole pies across multiple chain crusts; live store pricing | Delivery and carryout at 180 Crandon Blvd; no sit-down service published | Check today's official store page; a stable weekly schedule is not published Confirm live Checked Sources: pizza.dominos.com ↗ · www2.myfloridalicense.com ↗ |
| Stefano's | A Ritz-Carlton pool day | Wood-fired pizza; pie format and current prices are not published | Poolside at the Ritz-Carlton; non-guests should call the hotel because public access is not published | Daily 11 AM–5 PM Checked Sources: ritzcarlton.com ↗ |
| Sunset Point Wood Fired Pizzeria | A Neapolitan wood-fired causeway stop | 13-inch Neapolitan wood-fired pies; Marinara $16.99 / Margherita $18.99 | Dine-in, pickup, delivery, and reservations at 4400 Rickenbacker Causeway on Virginia Key, before Bear Cut | Check today — the restaurant site, ordering page, and Chamber publish conflicting schedules Conflicting schedules Checked Sources: sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · business.keybiscaynechamber.org ↗ · toasttab.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · miamidade.gov ↗ |
What is not counted
- Pizza Hut Express at 70 Crandon Boulevard is a limited-service brand counter inside Exprezo, so it is noted but not counted as a separate local restaurant. Source: Pizza Hut location ↗
- Pommodori was removed from the active guide. Florida's current restaurant-license extract does not show an active Pommodori license at its former suite, and current listings conflict with stale delivery pages. Source: www2.myfloridalicense.com ↗ · www2.myfloridalicense.com ↗ · wanderlog.com ↗ · ubereats.com ↗
Direct answers
Pizza in Key Biscayne: quick answers
Where should I get pizza in Key Biscayne?
Choose Miami Slice for a destination slice, Tutto for a sit-down wood-fired meal with pasta, Sir Pizza for local delivery and lower-cost pies, CRAFT for a mixed-menu group, Domino's for chain carryout or delivery, and Stefano's when you are already at the Ritz-Carlton. Sunset Point is the nearby wood-fired option on Virginia Key, not in the Village.
Sources: miamislicepizza.com ↗ · tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ · sirpizzakeybiscayne.com ↗ · craftmiami.us ↗ · pizza.dominos.com ↗ · ritzcarlton.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗
Which Key Biscayne pizza places deliver?
Tutto, Sir Pizza, CRAFT, and Domino's publish delivery or direct online-ordering options. Miami Slice publishes pickup ordering. Sunset Point publishes delivery from Virginia Key. Delivery zones and service windows change, so use each linked venue source before ordering.
Sources: tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ · sirpizzakeybiscayne.com ↗ · toasttab.com ↗ · pizza.dominos.com ↗ · toasttab.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗
Where can I buy pizza by the slice in Key Biscayne?
Miami Slice explicitly offers slices at its pop-up inside Flour & Weirdoughs. The other active venues in this guide publish whole-pie formats or do not clearly promise slices, so confirm before making a slice-only trip.
Sources: miamislicepizza.com ↗
Which pizza places have wood-fired pizza?
Tutto publishes wood-fired Italian pizza, Stefano's publishes poolside wood-fired pizza at the Ritz-Carlton, and Sunset Point publishes Neapolitan pizza from a wood-fired oven on Virginia Key.
Sources: tuttopizzapasta.com ↗ · ritzcarlton.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗
Is Sunset Point Pizzeria actually on Key Biscayne?
No. Sunset Point is at 4400 Rickenbacker Causeway in the former Miami Seaquarium parking area on Virginia Key. It is on the causeway route to Key Biscayne but is before Bear Cut Bridge and outside the Village of Key Biscayne.
Sources: sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · miamidade.gov ↗
How current are the prices and hours in this pizza guide?
Every comparison row shows its verification date and links to the restaurant or ordering source used. Exact prices are examples, not quotes. Where first-party hours conflict or change dynamically, the guide says ‘Check today’ and does not calculate an open-now answer.
Sources: miamislicepizza.com ↗ · toasttab.com ↗ · sunsetpointpizzeria.com ↗ · toasttab.com ↗
Editorial standards
How this guide is researched
What is included
We include active pizza-led restaurants and dedicated pizza operations in the Village or at the Ritz-Carlton, including Miami Slice's pop-up inside Flour & Weirdoughs, plus one clearly labeled causeway option that directly serves Key Biscayne. Limited-service brand counters inside another business are noted but not counted as separate local restaurants.
Source priority
We prioritize each restaurant's own menu, location, ordering, and reservation pages, then use Florida licensing, Miami-Dade, the Key Biscayne Chamber, or another traceable source to confirm identity and geography.
How to read “best for,” prices, and hours
‘Best for’ is an editorial shortcut based on format, access, menu, and service — not a paid ranking. Prices are dated examples. When hours conflict, we say so and suppress open-now claims and hours schema.
Freshness and corrections
The guide must be reviewed at least every 30 days. Venue detail changes can advance the page's structured-data modification date, but a successful URL check never refreshes a fact by itself. Send a correction.