Best Italian restaurants on Key Biscayne

7 italian restaurants on the island, hand-verified. See open-now status, hours, and where to reserve.

La Scala Italian Restaurant
Hours · check below

Italian $$$ Crandon Blvd ★ 4.7 · 89

Classic Italian dinner room — small, warm, with handmade pasta and a tight neighborhood feel. Dinner only, closed Sundays.

italiandinner-onlydate-night
Sir Pizza
Hours · check below

Pizza · Italian $ Crandon Blvd ★ 4.3 · 720

KB's pizza institution since 1969 — round pizzas, subs, calzones. Delivery-friendly, family staple.

pizzadeliverycheap-eats
Milanezza Kitchen Bar Market
Hours · check below

Argentine · Italian $$ Crandon Blvd ★ 4.6 · 1812

Casual Argentine–Italian kitchen and bar with a vintage feel — milanesas, hand-cut pasta, a full cocktail program. The kind of place locals end up at on a Tuesday and stay later than they planned.

barcasualargentine
Reserve ↗
Toscana Mare
Hours · check below

Italian · Seafood $$$ Towers of Key Biscayne ★ 4.6 · 63

Coastal Tuscan kitchen at the base of the Towers — handmade pasta, whole fish, an Italian-leaning wine list.

italianseafooddate-night
Reserve ↗
Tutto Pizza & Pasta
Hours · check below

Italian · Pizza $$ Galleria ★ 4.5 · 923

Pizza and pasta room from a long-running Miami Italian family — wood-fired pies and a deep pasta menu. Reliable for delivery.

pizzaitaliandelivery
Reserve ↗
Luma
Hours · check below

Italian $$$$ Ritz-Carlton ★ 4.7 · 13

Modern Italian coastal restaurant that opened with the Ritz-Carlton reopening in December 2025, replacing Lightkeepers. Chef Patrizio La Gioia (Per Se NYC, I Portici Bologna) leads a Josper-driven program of handmade pasta, whole fish, and seasonal vegetables over binchotan and oak coals. Breakfast 7–11 AM, dinner 5–10 PM, La Dolce Vita brunch weekends.

italianfine-dininghotel
Reserve ↗
Stefano's
Hours · check below

Pizza · Italian $$ Ritz-Carlton

Poolside pizzeria at the Ritz-Carlton — wood-fired pies, hotel-side dining.

pizzapoolsidecasual